Repository navigation
Different values in the Spark skill #579
Copy link
Copy link
Closed
Labels
bug: calculationNumerical differencesNumerical differences
Description
Check version
- I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog
Check for duplicates
- I've checked for duplicate open and closed issues by using the search function of the issue tracker
Check for support
- I've checked that the calculation is supposed to be supported. If it isn't please open a feature request instead (Red text is a feature request).
What platform are you running Path of Building on?
Windows
What is the value from the calculation in-game?
Skill Hit Damage: 27 to 478
Mana Cost: 34
Skill Average Hit: 301.25
Skill DPS: 744.09
Casts per second: 2.47
What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?
Skill Hit Damage: 26 to 478
Mana Cost: 37
Skill Average Hit: 300.6
Skill DPS: 751.6
Casts per second: 2.5
1.43 (base)
x 1.41 (increased/reduced)
x 1.24 (more/less)
= 2.50 cast per second
How to reproduce the issue
For testing, i have only one skill (spark) without any support gems and without any items.
Passive skills are the same.
Character build code
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Screenshots
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
bug: calculationNumerical differencesNumerical differences





Activity
PJacek commentedon Jan 24, 2025
rojosinalma commentedon Jan 25, 2025
Same problem here, difference is much bigger:
What platform are you running Path of Building on?
Windows 10
What is the value from the calculation in-game?
Note: Skill has +6 from items. Final level is 25
Skill Hit Damage: 747 - 14448
Mana Cost: 119
Skill Average Hit: 7597
Skill DPS: 26971.13
Casts per second: 3.55
What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?
Skill Hit Damage: 209 - 4135
Mana Cost: 113
Skill Average Hit: 2826.3
Skill DPS: 10295.9
Casts per second: 3.64
1.43 (base)
x 2.10 (increased/reduced)
x 1.22 (more/less)
= 3.64 cast per second
How to reproduce the issue
Import my build I guess?
Character build code
Screenshots
Skill
In game
PoB2
Gear
In game
PoB2
PoB Configuration
I think since the base calculation for the gem is wrong, the rest just adds up.
i.e:
I do see that the skill level is being calculated correctly and bonuses seem to be right too.
Let me know if you need anything else
EternisRequiem commentedon Jan 30, 2025
Also, some of my skill point totals don't seem to be adding up. May be a bug in game, I think doing refunding lost me skill points and that it didn't calculate the correct number of my 2nd weapon skill points (but that has nothing to do with weapon 1 where calcs are running)
MrDirtt commentedon Feb 4, 2025
I will also report that my Spark calculations are not matching in game values.
In game I see a Spark DPS number of ~124k, but POB reports it should be 160k
I have triple and quadruple checked my tree, my stats and skill slots etc...but everything looks to be correct. I also notice that my mana is a bit off (under 100 difference). I am glad to provide any info you might want.
https://maxroll.gg/poe2/pob/pi6e054z
Blitz54 commentedon Jun 19, 2026
I think this is fine to close for now. #2150 fixed a good amount of damage rounding. And since this issue was posted, many supports and skills were changed so we can't really use these numbers anymore to compare.
Of course, over time we will dial it all in. Probably :P