You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Reacted by fastAsTortoise, Robin Müller, Fangming Du, Gregory Emirian, rajulbhatnagar, Mohammad Kermani, kjartanvalur, Sergio Almécija, Mustafa, Thomas Bertels and 4 more
Reacted by Michael De Abreu, kjartanvalur, Andrii, Ed Sinek, radoslavpetranov, Zhoucheng Li, Tomasz Kula, Pedro Abreu, Bipul Das, Yoann Trouillet and 1 more
Reacted by kjartanvalur, Diana Zertuche, Carlos Henrique Spineli and Giseudo Oliveira
I really love how in Material 2 Autocomplete is not a black box component hiding the underlying input.
I was about to add a link to this issue, and then I saw this commit.
Thank you guys 👍
Guys, you can add thumbs down to the questions about ETA.
I really appreciate the hard work you guys put in Material 2, and I did not intend to hurt your feelings, I just really would like to know your plans on releasing autocomplete.
I guess Google is not doing Angular only out of generosity. Google wants developers to use their stack instead of React, and maybe even contribute code to Angular.
Angular 2 without Material 2 is simply not production ready. Material is THE ui recommendation of Google. This is why I (and many another developer) think that Material 2 library would need more resources.
@EladBezalel, honestly how could I understand your project management and generally just how the Material 2 team works, and what you work on? I based my view about autocomplete being silent on the kanban board you maintain for this feature.
We have projects that clients are waiting for. One happens to be blocked on autocomplete. I have to tell them something. So guys, do you have an estimated ETA for autocomplete? :)
@istvanszoboszlai Why? Why even ask for an ETA? Every of us have their own schedule (Even Angular team, and it is public, you can track their doing in the "Milestone" section of the issues), but you can't count with something that does not exist.
Beside the one mention to the "Milestone" section, the readme explicitly show this as a BETA, and it should NOT be used in production. I use it. You use it. Most of us are using it. But, we have to be grown up here, this is not yet ready. We have to wait. There are plenty of choice if you need an UI framework.
I'm sorry if I'm being rude, but when I get a notification about this I'm expecting that update to say "It's available guys, test it", but instead a found another post about "They should say when it will be ready", spoiler: They don't know. They are people, like us.
You can help. The code it's available, glob, there is even a branch just for the autocomplete. 😄
@michaeljota, I think you were definitely not rude.
Every software team has plans. I am simply curious about that. Maybe I miss something, but I cannot find up-to-date plans on this project. The milestones section is not up-to-date. So I cannot rely on that.
I am using Material2 with https://github.com/Teradata/covalent right now. They maintain nice documentation on their progress, and if I ask ETA than they simply answer.
@michaeljota, what I am really interested in: Which Angular2 UI framework do you think is there to choose? I know of none that is built with native Angular 2.
Like I say, they have a branch about autocomplete:
@jelbourn: I wouldn't exactly call the activity on master or on the autocomplete branch "silent".
For the others UI for Angular, one of the most complete support would be NgPrime, but for a most complete list, in Angular's website, in the resources section you can find many libraries for UI composition.
Sorry for offtopic posts, this is my last.
I did do my homework about half a year ago and there is not much change in the UI framework landscape.
PrimeNG is an Angular 2 wrapper over their jquery based UI elements. Not exactly native Angular 2.
On the other hand, look, even react has a mature, and awesome material UI library: http://www.material-ui.com/
I think Material 2 is the most important entry point for new users of Angular 2, and still - as awesome as it is - it is not treated as an extremely important project inside Google. This is pretty much a pity, IMHO.
@istvanszoboszlai reactmeaterial is 1.5year older than material2. but i agree with you !mateirla2 team need more resources-employes or so!! no news and very slow from google devs
You should notice that material-ui it's just an open source project, without any big company behind. So, why do you request more resources in an open source project with a big company behind? Instead you should just support the project, if you like. I think it's kind of unfair to request "more devs" from "google" cause this is a "google project". We all are just devs here. This still just another OSS. So, act alike.
Lol open source=open ok but when I start a project using this techno or when I join a team using this techo we aren't so free as you thnk! We depends! Before mask all behind opensource explain why these project are open why android is open if no profits?! stop telling opensource here! Its troll. I continue to think here need more resources to fight and be the most used fw
@jelbourn I hope I am not out of line when requesting this, but may this issue kindly be locked to collaborators only? This way the issue may constructively track progress without the overhead of accumulating inflammatory remarks.
Update: The initial version of autocomplete is getting pretty close. At this point, it's bare bones but usable. We are just ironing out any last bugs that come up. I can't give you an exact date when it will be available, but it will definitely go out with our next beta release (soon!).
@ehegnes I try to avoid closing threads because we do like hearing from the community, but I think you're right that this one is getting derailed a bit. I'm going to lock it for now. But if anyone wants to comment on potential bugs or feature requests for the autocomplete, please feel free to file a separate issue.
@kara i know it's locked but i have to reply to this one -
@istvanszoboszlai @istiti you should listen to @michaeljota,
I joined the material team a year and a half ago after contributing for more than a year to AngularJS material, I did it on my own free time and if I had an issue or a feature suggestion i opened issues and did PRs so not only i'd benefit from it, the entire community will.
It's super rude and egoistic to say - Google should put more devs on that cause they're probably using it - this project, as the Angular project is open-source, if you use it, contribute! don't demand that some company would throw more money over your problems!
If the company you work for doesn't understand the open-source community and how it's about to share and contribute, you should teach them or leave.
I get why people ask for ETA, but i don't get why some take this project or the people working for it as granted.
Activity
[-]mdAutocomplete[/-][+]md-autocomplete[/+]pramttl commentedon Jun 29, 2016
Any updates on this?
michaeljota commentedon Sep 18, 2016
Hi! If both issues are close, how this is not being updated? Is it being developed?
EladBezalel commentedon Sep 18, 2016
It's in early stages of development
michaeljota commentedon Sep 18, 2016
Thanks you! 😄
drew-codes commentedon Oct 17, 2016
Is regarding autocomplete support on popular text editors?
topherfangio commentedon Oct 17, 2016
This issue is in regards to the Material Autocomplete which you can view at https://material.google.com/components/text-fields.html#text-fields-auto-complete-text-field.
ioandr commentedon Oct 21, 2016
is there an estimation regarding the release ? thanks a lot!
22 remaining items
alirezamirian commentedon Feb 3, 2017
I really love how in Material 2 Autocomplete is not a black box component hiding the underlying input.
I was about to add a link to this issue, and then I saw this commit.
Thank you guys 👍
sobvan commentedon Feb 9, 2017
Guys, you can add thumbs down to the questions about ETA.
I really appreciate the hard work you guys put in Material 2, and I did not intend to hurt your feelings, I just really would like to know your plans on releasing autocomplete.
I guess Google is not doing Angular only out of generosity. Google wants developers to use their stack instead of React, and maybe even contribute code to Angular.
Angular 2 without Material 2 is simply not production ready. Material is THE ui recommendation of Google. This is why I (and many another developer) think that Material 2 library would need more resources.
@EladBezalel, honestly how could I understand your project management and generally just how the Material 2 team works, and what you work on? I based my view about autocomplete being silent on the kanban board you maintain for this feature.
We have projects that clients are waiting for. One happens to be blocked on autocomplete. I have to tell them something. So guys, do you have an estimated ETA for autocomplete? :)
michaeljota commentedon Feb 9, 2017
@istvanszoboszlai Why? Why even ask for an ETA? Every of us have their own schedule (Even Angular team, and it is public, you can track their doing in the "Milestone" section of the issues), but you can't count with something that does not exist.
Beside the one mention to the "Milestone" section, the readme explicitly show this as a BETA, and it should NOT be used in production. I use it. You use it. Most of us are using it. But, we have to be grown up here, this is not yet ready. We have to wait. There are plenty of choice if you need an UI framework.
I'm sorry if I'm being rude, but when I get a notification about this I'm expecting that update to say "It's available guys, test it", but instead a found another post about "They should say when it will be ready", spoiler: They don't know. They are people, like us.
You can help. The code it's available, glob, there is even a branch just for the autocomplete. 😄
sobvan commentedon Feb 9, 2017
@michaeljota, I think you were definitely not rude.
Every software team has plans. I am simply curious about that. Maybe I miss something, but I cannot find up-to-date plans on this project. The milestones section is not up-to-date. So I cannot rely on that.
I am using Material2 with https://github.com/Teradata/covalent right now. They maintain nice documentation on their progress, and if I ask ETA than they simply answer.
@michaeljota, what I am really interested in: Which Angular2 UI framework do you think is there to choose? I know of none that is built with native Angular 2.
michaeljota commentedon Feb 9, 2017
Like I say, they have a branch about autocomplete:
For the others UI for Angular, one of the most complete support would be NgPrime, but for a most complete list, in Angular's website, in the resources section you can find many libraries for UI composition.
sobvan commentedon Feb 9, 2017
Sorry for offtopic posts, this is my last.
I did do my homework about half a year ago and there is not much change in the UI framework landscape.
PrimeNG is an Angular 2 wrapper over their jquery based UI elements. Not exactly native Angular 2.
On the other hand, look, even react has a mature, and awesome material UI library: http://www.material-ui.com/
I think Material 2 is the most important entry point for new users of Angular 2, and still - as awesome as it is - it is not treated as an extremely important project inside Google. This is pretty much a pity, IMHO.
elvisbegovic commentedon Feb 9, 2017
@istvanszoboszlai reactmeaterial is 1.5year older than material2. but i agree with you !mateirla2 team need more resources-employes or so!! no news and very slow from google devs
michaeljota commentedon Feb 9, 2017
You should notice that material-ui it's just an open source project, without any big company behind. So, why do you request more resources in an open source project with a big company behind? Instead you should just support the project, if you like. I think it's kind of unfair to request "more devs" from "google" cause this is a "google project". We all are just devs here. This still just another OSS. So, act alike.
elvisbegovic commentedon Feb 9, 2017
Lol open source=open ok but when I start a project using this techno or when I join a team using this techo we aren't so free as you thnk! We depends! Before mask all behind opensource explain why these project are open why android is open if no profits?! stop telling opensource here! Its troll. I continue to think here need more resources to fight and be the most used fw
ehegnes commentedon Feb 9, 2017
@jelbourn I hope I am not out of line when requesting this, but may this issue kindly be locked to collaborators only? This way the issue may constructively track progress without the overhead of accumulating inflammatory remarks.
kara commentedon Feb 9, 2017
Update: The initial version of autocomplete is getting pretty close. At this point, it's bare bones but usable. We are just ironing out any last bugs that come up. I can't give you an exact date when it will be available, but it will definitely go out with our next beta release (soon!).
@ehegnes I try to avoid closing threads because we do like hearing from the community, but I think you're right that this one is getting derailed a bit. I'm going to lock it for now. But if anyone wants to comment on potential bugs or feature requests for the autocomplete, please feel free to file a separate issue.
EladBezalel commentedon Feb 12, 2017
@kara i know it's locked but i have to reply to this one -
@istvanszoboszlai @istiti you should listen to @michaeljota,
I joined the material team a year and a half ago after contributing for more than a year to AngularJS material, I did it on my own free time and if I had an issue or a feature suggestion i opened issues and did PRs so not only i'd benefit from it, the entire community will.
It's super rude and egoistic to say - Google should put more devs on that cause they're probably using it - this project, as the Angular project is open-source, if you use it, contribute! don't demand that some company would throw more money over your problems!
If the company you work for doesn't understand the open-source community and how it's about to share and contribute, you should teach them or leave.
I get why people ask for ETA, but i don't get why some take this project or the people working for it as granted.
kara commentedon Feb 17, 2017
Closing this, as the initial version of autocomplete is out in beta.2. We'll track future features in separate issues.