Repository navigation
Conversation
robhogan
force-pushed
the
pr1982
branch
3 times, most recently
from
September 28, 2026 12:22
fd8a027 to
5aabfda
Compare
Contributor
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Copilot review overview
🟡 Changes recommended
The reviewed implementation has unresolved correctness issues, including a critical mapping truncation bug.
Review effort: Lite
Findings: 1
Open (2)
What changed in this PR
Optimizes composeSourceMaps by encoding maps directly with Metro’s B64Builder.
Changes:
- Collects mappings in parallel arrays.
- Sorts, deduplicates, and encodes mappings directly.
- Preserves source-map metadata and ordering.
| File | Summary |
|---|---|
packages/metro-source-map/src/composeSourceMaps.js |
Direct encoding implementation. Findings include one critical line-gap truncation issue and two moderate correctness issues involving empty sources and null sorting. |
💡 Add a code-review agent skill or configure MCP servers for context-aware, tailored reviews. Learn more in the docs.
robhogan
force-pushed
the
pr1982
branch
3 times, most recently
from
September 29, 2026 17:44
1e9d87b to
f1fb49a
Compare
robhogan
force-pushed
the
pr1982
branch
4 times, most recently
from
October 5, 2026 14:17
35aa0c8 to
e332f80
Compare
robhogan
marked this pull request as ready for review
October 5, 2026 14:40
## Context `composeSourceMaps` built its output with `source-map`'s `SourceMapGenerator`, which allocates and validates an object per mapping and serialises by string concatenation: https://github.com/react/metro/blob/b7c20552a16a251507f753c3da23cc7d18488b6c/packages/metro-source-map/src/composeSourceMaps.js#L44-L56 On a large map that was most of the remaining time. ## This change This collects the composed mappings into parallel arrays and encodes them with Metro's own `B64Builder`. Output is unchanged, including source and name ordering, de-duplication, sorting and the error for an invalid mapping. This also fixes `B64Builder.markLines`, which grew its buffer at most once and silently dropped line markers that didn't fit. Without the fix, `composeSourceMaps` truncates a gap of more than about two million generated lines between mappings, which `SourceMapGenerator` handled. Metro's own `Generator` had the same bug. That puts Metro's composer level with Expo's `@jridgewell/remapping`-based one (~680ms on the same input), with more faithful output. It's the point of this stack: it makes the case for Expo's Hermes export path using Metro's composer rather than its own. `composeSourceMaps` is 20.6% faster than #1981 (95% CI 19.7-21.2%) and 3.25x faster than `main` (2,088ms -> 646ms on our benchmark app), with byte-identical output and no change in memory. ## Benchmark AI-driven. | | Time (median) | vs previous | vs `main` | Composition memory | vs previous | vs `main` | Peak RSS | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | `main` | 2,088ms (2,082 to 2,094) | | | 1,070MB (1,070 to 1,070) | | | 1,664MB | | #1981 | 805ms (802 to 811) | | -61.4% (-61.6 to -61.1) | 911MB (910 to 912) | | -14.9% (-15.0 to -14.7) | 1,505MB | | This PR | 646ms (641 to 650) | -20.6% (-21.2 to -19.7) | -69.2% (-69.3 to -69.0) | 914MB (907 to 915) | 0.0% (-0.4 to +0.3) | -14.8% (-15.2 to -14.6) | 1,508MB | ## Changelog ``` - **[Performance]**: `composeSourceMaps` encodes its output directly rather than through `source-map` - **[Fix]**: Source maps no longer lose lines after a gap of more than about two million unmapped generated lines ``` ## Test plan Compared against #1981 on 40,000 randomly generated compositions of one to three maps, including repeated and out-of-order mappings, names, unmapped positions and invalid mappings. Every output and every error message is identical. A new `B64Builder` test marks 3,145,728 lines, which previously produced 2,097,151 line markers. Benchmark (AI-driven): Mattermost Mobile 2.45.0 (React Native 0.83.9, Metro 0.83.7), iOS release bundle, unminified: 7,086 sources, 52.6MB bundle, 82.4MB flat source map. Composed with its `hermesc -O -output-source-map` map (hermes-compiler 0.14.1, 10.7MB, 1.84M segments). Timings are `composeSourceMaps` alone, excluding JSON parsing, over 105 rounds on Node 22.13.1 on an M5 Pro. Each round runs `main`, every PR in this stack and a memory baseline, in a shuffled order. Figures are medians with 95% bootstrap confidence intervals, for changes of the per-round paired ratio. Composition memory is peak RSS less that of the same process parsing both maps without composing them (594MB).
robhogan
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 21, 2026
Summary: Publish Metro 0.87.2 from `main`. Changelog: [Internal] Test plan: ``` node scripts/updateVersion.js 0.87.2 sl diff --stat ``` Only the 17 `packages/*/package.json` manifests change, and every `0.87.1` reference is replaced. Draft release notes (from the 95 commits in v0.87.1...main - internal-only changes omitted): ``` - **[Feature]**: Add a built-in `metro:runtime/*` specifier, resolvable from any importer, eg for `transformer.asyncRequireModulePath` (#2083 by @robhogan) - **[Feature]**: When `transformer.enableBabelRuntime` is `true`, pass Metro's own `@babel/runtime` (`metro:babel-runtime`) and its installed version to Babel presets via caller data (#1957 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Fix stale resolutions after adding a nearer `package.json` or retargeting a symlinked directory, which previously needed a restart (#1948 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Packages and directories named with an asset extension (eg `lodash.zip`) resolve as modules rather than failing as assets (#2055 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Fall through to parent conditions when a nested `"exports"` or `"imports"` condition has no matching target (#2074 by @maximilliangrand) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: An exact `"exports"` or `"imports"` subpath with a `null` or unmatched target no longer resolves through a less specific subpath pattern (#1987 by @kwy404) - **[Fix]**: Use indexed watch folder paths (`[metro-watchFolders]/N/`) for assets outside `projectRoot` (#1892 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix `/[metro-project]/` and `/[metro-watchFolders]/` bundle serving on Windows (#2015 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Prevent HMR crash on `[metro-watchFolders]` or `[metro-project]` URLs (#2017 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Remove erroneous `[metro-project]` and `[metro-watchFolders]` resolution of entry points from the API and CLI (#2030 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Fix backslashes in async bundle paths on Windows (`includeAsyncPaths`) (#1938 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix stale modules on the client when a file is deleted and recreated during a build, or changes during a build that fails (#2007 by @YevheniiKotyrlo) - **[Fix]**: Fix files created or modified while Metro starts up being missed until restart (#2054 by @cpruijsen) - **[Fix]**: Fix watch mode losing files when a directory replaces a file or symlink, eg when unlinking a package (#2009 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix the fallback (Linux/Windows) watcher hanging on stop, and missing changes in a replaced directory, after a watch error (#1967 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix the fallback watcher missing changes when a directory changes faster than Windows can report (#1967 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Close the watch handles of a deleted directory and every directory under it in `FallbackWatcher`, which kept the process busy on Windows (#2004 by @YevheniiKotyrlo) - **[Fix]**: `metro-file-map`: Fix removing a non-active duplicate mock changing which mock is active (#1756 by @durvesh1992) - **[Fix]**: Propagate transformer initialisation errors from `Bundler` (#1854 by @Boulea7) - **[Fix]**: Release transform workers and file watchers when Metro fails to initialise (#1963 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Ignore hyphenated and namespaced SVG attributes (eg `stroke-width`) when reading SVG asset dimensions (#1972 by @GabrielDumbrava) - **[Fix]**: Fix generated positions when iterating the mappings of indexed source maps, eg in `composeSourceMaps` (#1976 by @kwy404) - **[Fix]**: `composeSourceMaps` keeps every mapping at a generated column that the last map maps more than once (#1981 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Source maps no longer lose lines after a gap of more than about two million unmapped generated lines (#1983 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: `metro-symbolicate` no longer fails on stack frames with no source position, such as `[native code]:0:0` in crash reporter output (#1891 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix `metro-symbolicate` parsing of stack frames with Windows absolute paths (#1939 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: `metro-source-map`: Faster `Consumer` decoding and position lookups, and `composeSourceMaps` encodes its output directly - 3.2x faster composition of a bundle map with its Hermes map, using 15% less memory (#1978, #1979, #1980, #1983 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: Resolver: Ask for the package of a directory once for all extension candidates, and check `hierarchicalLookup` candidates from their own file map nodes. First-pass resolution is 35% faster (172ms -> 113ms on a mid-size RN app), net of a ~3% first-build cost from dropping `PackageCache`'s closest-package memo, which also cuts the resolver's retained heap by 37% (#1945, #1946, #1948 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: 33% faster non-Watchman file system crawl on startup (#1677 by @kitten) - **[Deprecated]**: `server.enhanceMiddleware` logs a deprecation warning when set to anything other than its default. Use `server.unstable_middleware` or `server.unstable_priorityMiddleware` (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Deprecated]**: `runServer`'s `unstable_extraMiddleware` option. Use `unstable_priorityMiddleware`, which runs the same middleware in the same place (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Deprecated]**: String values of `transformer.enableBabelRuntime` (use `true`) (#1957 by @robhogan) - **[Types]**: Add TypeScript definitions for `metro-runtime` modules, and generate (rather than hand-maintain) types for `metro-file-map` workers (#1996 by @robhogan) > NOTE: Experimental features are not covered by semver and can change at any time. - **[Experimental]**: Add `server.unstable_middleware` and `server.unstable_priorityMiddleware` config options, and `runServer` options of the same names, to add middleware after and before Metro's own. `mergeConfig` combines them from both configs: a later config's `unstable_middleware` runs last and its `unstable_priorityMiddleware` runs first (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Experimental]**: Add `server.unstable_onServerCreated` config option and `runServer` option of the same name, called with Metro's server instance before the HTTP server listens (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Experimental]**: Fix mismatched asset paths in (release) builds under `unstable_serverRoot`, make them always relative to `projectRoot` (#1917 by @robhogan) **Full Changelog**: v0.87.1...v0.87.2 ```
robhogan
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 21, 2026
Summary: Publish Metro 0.87.2 from `main`. Changelog: [Internal] Test plan: ``` node scripts/updateVersion.js 0.87.2 sl diff --stat ``` Only the 17 `packages/*/package.json` manifests change, and every `0.87.1` reference is replaced. Draft release notes (from the 95 commits in v0.87.1...main - internal-only changes omitted): ``` - **[Feature]**: Add a built-in `metro:runtime/*` specifier, resolvable from any importer, eg for `transformer.asyncRequireModulePath` (#2083 by @robhogan) - **[Feature]**: When `transformer.enableBabelRuntime` is `true`, pass Metro's own `@babel/runtime` (`metro:babel-runtime`) and its installed version to Babel presets via caller data (#1957 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Fix stale resolutions after adding a nearer `package.json` or retargeting a symlinked directory, which previously needed a restart (#1948 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Packages and directories named with an asset extension (eg `lodash.zip`) resolve as modules rather than failing as assets (#2055 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: Fall through to parent conditions when a nested `"exports"` or `"imports"` condition has no matching target (#2074 by @maximilliangrand) - **[Fix]**: Resolver: An exact `"exports"` or `"imports"` subpath with a `null` or unmatched target no longer resolves through a less specific subpath pattern (#1987 by @kwy404) - **[Fix]**: Use indexed watch folder paths (`[metro-watchFolders]/N/`) for assets outside `projectRoot` (#1892 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix `/[metro-project]/` and `/[metro-watchFolders]/` bundle serving on Windows (#2015 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Prevent HMR crash on `[metro-watchFolders]` or `[metro-project]` URLs (#2017 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Remove erroneous `[metro-project]` and `[metro-watchFolders]` resolution of entry points from the API and CLI (#2030 by @motiz88) - **[Fix]**: Fix backslashes in async bundle paths on Windows (`includeAsyncPaths`) (#1938 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix stale modules on the client when a file is deleted and recreated during a build, or changes during a build that fails (#2007 by @YevheniiKotyrlo) - **[Fix]**: Fix files created or modified while Metro starts up being missed until restart (#2054 by @cpruijsen) - **[Fix]**: Fix watch mode losing files when a directory replaces a file or symlink, eg when unlinking a package (#2009 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix the fallback (Linux/Windows) watcher hanging on stop, and missing changes in a replaced directory, after a watch error (#1967 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix the fallback watcher missing changes when a directory changes faster than Windows can report (#1967 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Close the watch handles of a deleted directory and every directory under it in `FallbackWatcher`, which kept the process busy on Windows (#2004 by @YevheniiKotyrlo) - **[Fix]**: `metro-file-map`: Fix removing a non-active duplicate mock changing which mock is active (#1756 by @durvesh1992) - **[Fix]**: Propagate transformer initialisation errors from `Bundler` (#1854 by @Boulea7) - **[Fix]**: Release transform workers and file watchers when Metro fails to initialise (#1963 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Ignore hyphenated and namespaced SVG attributes (eg `stroke-width`) when reading SVG asset dimensions (#1972 by @GabrielDumbrava) - **[Fix]**: Fix generated positions when iterating the mappings of indexed source maps, eg in `composeSourceMaps` (#1976 by @kwy404) - **[Fix]**: `composeSourceMaps` keeps every mapping at a generated column that the last map maps more than once (#1981 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Source maps no longer lose lines after a gap of more than about two million unmapped generated lines (#1983 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: `metro-symbolicate` no longer fails on stack frames with no source position, such as `[native code]:0:0` in crash reporter output (#1891 by @robhogan) - **[Fix]**: Fix `metro-symbolicate` parsing of stack frames with Windows absolute paths (#1939 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: `metro-source-map`: Faster `Consumer` decoding and position lookups, and `composeSourceMaps` encodes its output directly - ~3.2x faster composition of a bundle map with its Hermes map, using ~15% less memory (#1978, #1979, #1980, #1983 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: Resolver: Ask for the package of a directory once for all extension candidates, and check `hierarchicalLookup` candidates from their own file map nodes. First-pass resolution is ~35% faster, net of a ~3% first-build cost from dropping `PackageCache`'s closest-package memo, which also cuts the resolver's retained heap by ~37% (#1945, #1946, #1948 by @robhogan) - **[Performance]**: ~33% faster non-Watchman file system crawl on startup (#1677 by @kitten) - **[Deprecated]**: `server.enhanceMiddleware` logs a deprecation warning when set to anything other than its default. Use `server.unstable_middleware` or `server.unstable_priorityMiddleware` (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Deprecated]**: `runServer`'s `unstable_extraMiddleware` option. Use `unstable_priorityMiddleware`, which runs the same middleware in the same place (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Deprecated]**: String values of `transformer.enableBabelRuntime` (use `true`) (#1957 by @robhogan) - **[Types]**: Add TypeScript definitions for `metro-runtime` modules, and generate (rather than hand-maintain) types for `metro-file-map` workers (#1996 by @robhogan) > NOTE: Experimental features are not covered by semver and can change at any time. - **[Experimental]**: Add `server.unstable_middleware` and `server.unstable_priorityMiddleware` config options, and `runServer` options of the same names, to add middleware after and before Metro's own. `mergeConfig` combines them from both configs: a later config's `unstable_middleware` runs last and its `unstable_priorityMiddleware` runs first (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Experimental]**: Add `server.unstable_onServerCreated` config option and `runServer` option of the same name, called with Metro's server instance before the HTTP server listens (#2031 by @vzaidman) - **[Experimental]**: Fix mismatched asset paths in (release) builds under `unstable_serverRoot`, make them always relative to `projectRoot` (#1917 by @robhogan) **Full Changelog**: v0.87.1...v0.87.2 ```
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.


Context
composeSourceMapsbuilt its output withsource-map'sSourceMapGenerator, which allocates and validates an object per mapping and serialises by string concatenation:metro/packages/metro-source-map/src/composeSourceMaps.js
Lines 44 to 56 in b7c2055
On a large map that was most of the remaining time.
This change
This collects the composed mappings into parallel arrays and encodes them with Metro's own
B64Builder. Output is unchanged, including source and name ordering, de-duplication, sorting and the error for an invalid mapping.This also fixes
B64Builder.markLines, which grew its buffer at most once and silently dropped line markers that didn't fit. Without the fix,composeSourceMapstruncates a gap of more than about two million generated lines between mappings, whichSourceMapGeneratorhandled. Metro's ownGeneratorhad the same bug.That puts Metro's composer level with Expo's
@jridgewell/remapping-based one (~680ms on the same input), with more faithful output. It's the point of this stack: it makes the case for Expo's Hermes export path using Metro's composer rather than its own.composeSourceMapsis 20.6% faster than #1981 (95% CI 19.7-21.2%) and 3.25x faster thanmain(2,088ms -> 646ms on our benchmark app), with byte-identical output and no change in memory.Benchmark
AI-driven.
mainmainmainChangelog
Test plan
Compared against #1981 on 40,000 randomly generated compositions of one to three maps, including repeated and out-of-order mappings, names, unmapped positions and invalid mappings. Every output and every error message is identical.
A new
B64Buildertest marks 3,145,728 lines, which previously produced 2,097,151 line markers.Benchmark (AI-driven): Mattermost Mobile 2.45.0 (React Native 0.83.9, Metro 0.83.7), iOS release bundle, unminified: 7,086 sources, 52.6MB bundle, 82.4MB flat source map. Composed with its
hermesc -O -output-source-mapmap (hermes-compiler 0.14.1, 10.7MB, 1.84M segments). Timings arecomposeSourceMapsalone, excluding JSON parsing, over 105 rounds on Node 22.13.1 on an M5 Pro. Each round runsmain, every PR in this stack and a memory baseline, in a shuffled order. Figures are medians with 95% bootstrap confidence intervals, for changes of the per-round paired ratio. Composition memory is peak RSS less that of the same process parsing both maps without composing them (594MB).